20+ Thoughtful Personalized Valentine’s Gifts for Every Budget!

*FYI - this post may contain affiliate links, which means we earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you purchase from them. Also, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Check out our Privacy Policy and Disclosure. for more info.

Valentine’s Day is kind of a big deal. And, if you’re looking for something a little more sentimental than another piece of jewelry, it can add some extra and, well, unneeded pressure. And, believe us, we know there’s already enough pressure this time of year.

But don’t worry: we’re here to help! We know the only gifts that are as unique and special as you need them to be are custom Valentine’s gifts. This isn’t just a gift—it’s your chance to make a statement (and, of course, out-gift your partner).

So, without further ado, here are the best custom Valentine’s day gifts for every budget and every relationship!

Pin for later:

Best Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts Under $20

If you’re shopping on a budget but still want to ensure this Valentine’s Day is truly special, don’t worry. You’re in luck! There are plenty of personalized Valentine’s gifts for her and him available for those balling on a budget. You don’t have to spend a fortune. You just have to find the right gift. And, lucky for you, we’ve found the best personalized Valentine’s presents under $20! Here are our favorites.

Personalized Valentine’s Day Teddy Bears

Soft, adorable, but most importantly, affordable, these great personalized stuffed animals are sure to climb the ranks of your Valentine’s favorite stuffed animals. Just know it can sometimes be a war of attrition, but yours will eventually beat out the others.

Select between a wide variety of bears (and other animals), select the text color, and input what you’d like to be stitched into their feet and chest. These stuffed animals and their adorable renderings of prison tattoos are sure to be a hit!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via CraftyMaggiesDesigns on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Leather Bracelet

Looking for the perfect valentine’s present for him? Well, this personalized bracelet might be just what you’re looking for because, while it has a tough leather exterior, there’s nothing but saccharine sweetness beneath it. Which I guess could be how he is.

With a wide variety of sizes to choose from, as well as different engraving options, this will definitely be cherished! Just input what messages you’d like engraved, and every time he sees this bracelet he’ll be reminded of how much you care.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via GoWildBoutique on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Coffee Mug

Looking for that special gift that will send your partner into the day with momentum and encouragement? This is it! Because, the truth is, morning’s can be tough. And that’s why this personalized coffee mug is so much more valuable than you might assume.

With sizing and color options, you can select between a wide variety of letter combos and personalization details to make this mug a true portrait of your guys’ relationship. Whether it’s used for wine or coffee is unimportant. What’s important is what it conveys.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via Her2ndChance on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

I Wrote a Book About Us

If you’re not opposed to doing a little extra work, then this I Wrote a Book About Us book is one of the best gifts to get. Because it’ll say everything you wish you could. Sometimes the perfect and most encapsulating words can be elusive.

At 64 pages, this book comes with a number of prompts and blanks for you to fill in. It’s a great way to show how much you care (especially if getting inspired is difficult—we’ve all been there). But, also, you guys can fill it out together. Which could be fun, too!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Personalized Boxer Shorts

Looking for a way to remind him or her whose property they are every time they, well, look down at their underwear? Then these personalized boxer shorts are the perfect gift. Especially if you guys have a good sense of humor!

Though it doesn’t have to be your face. (But, honestly, what’s the point of getting these and not using your face? That’s like buying a laptop to use as a paperweight). 100% polyester and machine washable, just upload an image and you’re good to go!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Best Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts Under $50

So nothing so far has done it for you. But, don’t worry, we get it. You’re probably willing to spend a little more because, like any good investment, it’ll pay dividends down the road. And, lucky for you, there are plenty of stellar options available that are only marginally more expensive but exponentially more touching! It doesn’t matter if you’re looking for custom Valentine’s gifts for him or her—we’ve got something for everyone! Here are our favorites.

Personalized 3D Illusion Lamp

If you’re on the hunt for something that pops—something that makes a statement and is, for lack of a better term, of the times—then this personalized 3D illusion lamp should be a no brainer. Extra people necessitate extra gifts—and there’s nothing wrong with that!

With hearts or infinite styles to choose from, you can really make a splash with this one. Just enter your names and the dates you’d like commemorated, and then this beautiful wood and acrylic custom present will be ready to get those sparks flying.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via DSGiftStudio on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Unique Valentine’s Gift Idea Custom Street Map Sign

Most couples, really like to think their relationship consecrates certain parts of the world. And, while it’s a little self-centered, that’s kind of what relationships are all about. And that’s precisely who this custom street map sign is perfect for!

With a variety of framing additions and options available, just input your first names and the date you’d like to pay homage to. Then input the full address or coordinates, and you’ll be good to go. There’s nothing wrong with a little self-importance!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via EmmaAndTheBean on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Compass

Those on the hunt for engraved Valentine’s gifts (particularly for him) rejoice. This personalized compass is sure to get it through their (in my case, thick) head they’d be lost and utterly rudderless without you. Sometimes us guys need it spelled out for us.

With a number of engraving options available, as well as a fantastic leather case, all you have to do is provide what missive you’d like inscribed. That’s not even the best part—you can even have it done in your own handwriting. It doesn’t get more special than that!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via EliteCustomDesignUSA on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Star Map

Are you shopping for someone who’s into astrology—like someone who knows the ins-and-outs of every zodiac sign? If so, then this personalized star map might be perfect. And, let’s face it, this kind of thing will definitely go a long way.

With various sizing and color options, you can truly make this map as special as you would like it. Just input the text you’d like written and its layout, and then input the date and location you’d like coordinated, and you’ll have a truly special gift ready to awe!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via WoodLifePrints on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Wood Plaque

Maybe this one is a little, well, basic. But that doesn’t mean it won’t be appreciated. And, to be honest, there’s something to the old adage: classics are classic for a reason. Because this personalized wood plaque is sappy enough get the job done.

With a rustic color, marks, and knots, each plaque is unique in more than just design. And it’s hard not to appreciate that kind of thing. Just send them your names, a message, and a date, and you’ll have a tried and true gift for this special day.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Best Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts Under $100

So you’re still not satisfied with anything we’ve found. And, truthfully, we have to admit we’re impressed. Because we can only assume that you won’t settle for anything but the best. Or you maybe didn’t make last Valentine’s all it could be and this is your way of, like, making amends. Regardless—we’re here for you. Because, while money can’t replace thoughtfulness, it’s definitely a nice supplement. So let’s get into it. Here are our favorite personalized Valentine’s Day presents under $100!

Personalized Box of Valentine’s Chocolates

While Valentine’s chocolates may seem a little, well, vanilla when you consider everything else you could get, this tiered and personalized box of Valentine’s chocolates is a little different. It goes to show that there are, indeed, levels to this.

With a message of your choice to be written on the beautifully made gift box (with a ribbon), this is a gift that’ll definitely win you some points. But it’s so much more than that. It includes 25 Ferrero Rocher chocolates, artificial flowers, and more!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via HappyBoxLLC on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Tree Wood Carving

Perfect for someone who’s into, like, the Rom-Com thing, this awesome personalized tree wood carving is a great way to give them the experience of one of the most commonly used tropes they’ll also be able to hold on forever.

Made out of Baltic birch plywood, all you have to do is provide them with the initials and date you’d like them to etch in. Then wait. But believe us when we say this: this is the kind of thing that’ll definitely raise the bar. So be prepared!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Personalized Valentine’s Day Necklace

It can sometimes be tough to find necklaces like this that aren’t, well, tough on the eyes. But here we are with this amazing personalized Valentine’s Day necklace that will surely remind them of how thoughtful you are every time they sport it!

Made of sterling silver and with gold filling, this elegant necklace will undoubtedly bring you guys closer. It has two sterling silver disks stamped with your names attached to a gold-filled heart to keep them together always. You can’t go wrong with this!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Personalized Connect Four

Do you and your significant other like playing games the old fashioned way? If so, this great personalized connect four game set could be the perfect gift. Plus, when things get, er, contentious competitive, maybe the hearts will help you guys simmer down.

Select the primary wood color and the shapes of the holes, and then decide on the colors for the pucks. You can even have some holes customized to be text. Handmade out of birch wood, this is certainly a gift they’ll be trying to beat for years to come!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via Huntsbrook on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Watch

While it seems like the conventional watch with a conventional clock-face may be going the way of the dinosaur and horse-and-buggy, that doesn’t mean guys don’t like wearing them. Simply put: these personalized watches will never go out of style

But the best part of it all is that have it engraved with the message of your choice. Personalized gifts don’t always look this good, either, so this one will definitely be hard to pass up. Made with high-quality woods and metals, this is a can’t-miss!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via MyFaveGift on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Best Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts Over $100

If you’ve found yourself in this big-baller section, it’s safe to assume you’re in it for the long haul. In other words, you’re probably looking for personalized Valentine’s gifts for your husband or wife. And, after so many years together, the stakes are probably raised. But don’t worry—we’re here for you. Though, in all honesty, I can’t help but suspect there’s a chance you’re simply in the doghouse and trying to grease some palms to let you out. But that’s neither here nor there. Here are our favorite luxury personalized Valentine’s presents!

Personalized Pushpin World Map

If you and your partner are both globetrotters—especially if you guys are always planning your next international adventure—then this personalized pushpin world map is a great gift to help you guys, well, keep score (that’s what travellers do, right?).

Made out of Cumala wood and personalized with your names, this map has a vintage feel, and it comes with 100 pushpins to get started! Whether you’re just starting your travels or seasoned vets, this is the kind of gift that will, if nothing else, inspire you both!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Custom Wood Map

If you and your partner met have a place that’s near and dear to your heart—like, it’s practically a third party in your guys’ relationship—then this custom wood map is the best way to pay tribute to such a venerable locale!

Select the size and frame color, and then just input the city you’d like them to engrave. And, if you’re a stickler for details, you can even have the map revolving around an address. And don’t forget the engraving on the back—that’ll put this over the edge!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via FrontierDesignsAK on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Valentine’s Jewelry Box

This is the kind of gift you want to get someone who you’ve already inundated with every conceivable piece of jewelry and jewelry configuration. This custom Valentine’s jewelry box will be like the Valentine’s shrine for all their other Valentine’s gifts.

Simply select between the two styles, and then choose where you’d like this beautiful piece to be hand engraved. Afterwards, you just have to input what message you’d like included, and you’ll have a gift that feels full-circle in no time.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via OrienTurk on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Ring

Speaking of jewelry, if you’re still looking for a special, personalized piece of jewelry—particularly a custom ring—this personalized initial ring is everything you’ve been looking for! Honestly, who doesn’t love seeing their initials gilded and diamond studded?

Select between rose gold, yellow gold, and white gold, and input their ring size. Then just input the initial you’d like included. Made out of natural diamonds, this ring looks great and is sure to hold a special place in the recipient’s heart (and collection)!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via BocajNarima on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Personalized Wood Map with Personalized Pins

This is a different kind of map that’s just as amazing, if not more so. It’s particularly great for those who don’t want a, well, traditional map hanging around. This personalized wood map with personalized pins is sure to be appreciated!

Now, let’s get into what makes this so great. First of all, you can personalize the pins to commemorate where you had all your firsts. You can even personalize the map with a date and your names. This map is sure to keep your wanderlust alive!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via PaperAnniversaryLove on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Hopefully our list helped you find the personalized Valentine’s gifts you were looking for!

We’re convinced we’ve provided you with the definitive list of personalized Valentine’s presents. Whether you were looking for luxury or budget presents, or personalized Valentine’s Day gifts for her or him, there’s something touching for everyone!

If you have any questions, comments, or concerns, please don’t hesitate to ask! We know this is probably a big deal. And you do, too. Even if you’re pretending it isn’t. So make it count! You’ll reap the rewards for this one in the long run.

Leave a Comment