40+ Thoughtful Gifts for Pizza Lovers That Will Earn You a Pizza Their Heart

*FYI - this post may contain affiliate links, which means we earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you purchase from them. Also, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Check out our Privacy Policy and Disclosure. for more info.

There aren’t many foods as universally beloved as pizza. It’s one of the only dishes you can serve with almost absolute certainty everyone can at least tolerate. But, still, that doesn’t mean that pizza lovers are always easy to please.

We understand finding the perfect presents for pizza lovers can be difficult. Because, honestly, a simple taste can complicate shopping. If you’re wondering what exactly would be great pizza gift ideas, you’ve come to the right place!

It doesn’t matter if you’re looking for pizza gifts for him or pizza gifts for her, pizza gifts for Christmas, pizza themed presents, pizza related presents, or simply the best gift ideas for pizza lovers. We’ve got you covered by scouring the Internet for gift ideas so you don’t have to.

So, without further ado, here are the best gifts for pizza lovers that will be as appreciated as a midnight pizza delivery after a few too many drinks!

Pin these ideas for later:


Best lAST-mINUTE Pizza gIFTS FROM aMAZON

Shopping last minute? We offer an extensive list of pizza gifts below, but If you’re looking for fun pizza themed gifts that will deliver promptly, here are some ideas for pizza gifts from Amazon that offer fast shipping:

  • These hilarious pizza bandages
  • These fun pizza socks
  • These adorable pizza fairy lights
  • This epic pizza blanket
  • This ridiculously awesome pizza pouch
  • This awesome pizza fanny pack
  • This perfect gift card they’re sure to love
  • This cool bike shaped pizza cutter
Photo by Chad Montano on Unsplash

Best Gifts for Pizza Lovers Under $20

If you’re looking specifically for pizza lovers’ presents, it’s important not to underestimate their expectations! But, lucky for you, if you’re shopping for pizza gifts for him or pizza gifts for her on a budget, there are plenty of affordable options that don’t have to carve out a huge slice of your bank account.

Here are some budget-friendly ideas:


Cheesy Pizza Chalk Set

If you’re shopping for someone with kids who love pizza (let’s be honest—that’s pretty much every kid), this is the perfect gift! It’s also particularly great for teachers. Especially if their favorite day of the year is their pizza party.

This great cheesy pizza chalk set is one of the best gifts for a pizza enthusiast! Each piece of sidewalk chalk is made to resemble a pizza slice. Plus, they have a special glaze that recreates the greasy goodness of real pizza slices!

This is a great gift perfectly tailored to diminutive hands. Kids of all ages would love to use these chalks, which handily come in sets of four. No doubt, these are great pizza enthusiast gifts to turn every day into a pizza party!

Click here to check prices and reviews.  

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

Press and Measure Herb Infuser

If you’re shopping for a pizza lover—and we’re talking a true pizza lover and not a pizza imposter, or, dare I say? A pizza poser—this is a great gift to get! Because, chances are, their love of pizza is symptomatic of a greater love for Italian cuisine.

This press and measure herb infuser is one of the best pizza enthusiast presents for pizza lovers who have a more general love for Italian food. It infuses herbs in their favorite oils in a way that’s both refreshing and understated.

This gift is easy to use and would be particularly perfect for pizza lovers who make their own pizza. Or pasta. Or who just want some herb-infused oil to dip bread in. These are great presents for any pizza enthusiast with a broader enthusiasm for Italian cuisine!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

Personalized Pizza Cutter

If you’re shopping for unique accessories for pizza lovers, look no further. Because, honestly, without an adequate tool to divide pizza into equal slices, this world would undoubtedly degenerate into chaos (as if 2020 isn’t chaotic enough).

This great personalized pizza cutter is one of the most perfect presents for any pizza enthusiast! Just input the font you’d like included on the handle and enter what you’d like engraved. These slicers are made out of sturdy bamboo.

No pizza lover is complete without their trusty pizza cutter. And, if they have yet to procure a truly special pizza slicer, this is perfect! You can’t go wrong with these pizza enthusiast presents. And, hopefully, this will earn you a few free slices.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via CustomGoodsForYou on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

NYC Pizza Rescue Kit

If you’re shopping for pizza enthusiast gifts for a pizza lover who’s away from home—particularly if that home is New York City—you won’t find many better gifts for your pizza enthusiast then this right here!

This great NYC pizza rescue kit equips them with everything they need to turn an inedible and repugnant local slice of pizza into something palatable and respectable. It comes with black truffle salt, Italian seasoning blend, and crushed Aleppo pepper.

This kit is the perfect gift for that pizza lover who’s always underwhelmed by pizza at their new home base. And, if you’re shopping for this kind of person, maybe using these spices will be just what you need to open your eyes to what you’re missing. Though it may leave you just as jaded and you’re POV just as jaundiced. But you’ve been warned.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via SullivanTeaShop on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Best Gifts for Pizza Lovers Under $50

If you’re still looking for the perfect pizza lovers presents, we have to admit, we’re impressed. And, honestly, it’s safe to assume this is the kind of pizza lover you don’t even count slices with when eating together. Because they’re that special.

Well, if you’re looking for pizza gifts for Christmas or birthdays that are a little more expensive but worth it, here are our favorite presents for pizza lovers that are worth the extra splurge:


Custom Wood Pizza Peel and Rocker

If you’re shopping for someone who loves making their own pizza, these are the perfect accessories for pizza lovers to get! Because a process so revered deserves it’s own special tools to truly convey that it’s more than cooking—it’s art.

This great custom wood pizza peel and rocker is made out of bamboo wood. All you have to do is input what you’d like to be laser engraved and make all the necessary design specifications. It works just as well as a decoration, too.

This is a great gift that any pizza lover would appreciate because there’s not a whole lot that recognizes the art that is pizza making. And, if you’re shopping for someone who considers themselves a pizza auteur, you can’t go wrong with this one!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via TwoLineJump on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Italian Cheesemaking Kit

This is a great gift for two kinds of pizza lovers. Firstly, it’s perfect for pizza lovers who—as we’ve discussed before—love all Italian cuisine. But it’s also perfect for people who love pizza but have yet to expand their tastes beyond that.

This great Italian cheesemaking kit comes with everything they need to make ten different kinds of delicious Italian cheeses. They just need to add milk. The kit includes all necessary equipment and ingredients, including real cheesemaking cultures.

So if you’re shopping for someone who loves pizza but could do with a little, uh, culture, this is perfect. Because, honestly, there are plenty of those folks out there. But even just for someone who loves Italian cuisine, this will also be truly unforgettable.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

Wine Pairing Towel Set

Again if you’re shopping for pizza lovers gifts for a pizza lover who also loves Italian cuisine (there’s a tongue twister), these kinds of gifts are complementary. They’re also great for pizza lovers who need to evolve past their beloved cheese and bread pie.

This great wine pairing towel set comes covered with 68 popular wines and 56 different foods. It makes for 3,808 different pairings. So, if you’re shopping for someone who loves both wine and pizza (and, of course, Italian food), this might be perfect.

Now, it’s worth noting that for self-proclaimed pizza enthusiasts, the concept of 3,808 different pairings of different kinds of foods is probably unfathomable. So maybe framing it differently (e.g. in terms of pizza toppings) will make this easier to understand. 

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

Twist Decanter

Not every pizza lover will like wine. In fact, there are plenty of pizza lovers out there who’d prefer a soda to accompany their sumptuous heart-clogging, circular spread. But, if you’re shopping for one of these more refined pizza lovers, this gift is perfect.

This awesome twist decanter is one of the most unique pizza lovers gifts out. If nothing else, then at least for its shape. Its unique design allows the entire bottle of wine to “aerate” twice: once as you pour it in, and again as you pour it out.

So if you’re shopping for a pizza lover who also happens to believe in this stuff (because this kind of thing can feel a bit like believing in magic to the uninitiated), this is perfect. Plus, maybe you’ll get some free drinks and pizza. Which is nothing short of a win.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

Best Gifts for Pizza LOvers Under $100

So you haven’t found anything that’s cut it so far. Well, don’t worry – there are plenty of great unique pizza presents still out there! Here are the best and most unique pizza gifts out that may cost a little more but are definitely worth the heftier price tag:


Row Boat Serving Bowl

This is a great gift to get two different kinds of pizza lovers. The first is, of course, the kind of pizza lover that likes serving pasta or salad out of this kind of thing. And the second is the kind of pizza lover who could stand to eat a few more veggies.

This great row boat serving bowl comes with sheesham wood serving utensils. It’s shaped like a rowboat, so it’s perfect for pizza lovers with a nautical sensibility. This serving bowl is perfectly suited to serve both pasta and salad out of it.

So if you’re shopping for a pizza lover who also loves pasta, or a pizza lover who could use a few more veggies in their diet, this is a great gift! Plus, it’ll work just as well as a decoration. So the possibilities are pretty much endless with this one.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

Ranch to Table Server

Ostensibly, there are two different kinds of pizza lovers. There are those pizza lovers who can’t resist drizzling ranch dressing on each slice they eat, and there are those who consider these people blasphemous heathens. This is perfect for the former.

This great ranch to table server will perfectly accommodate both those more dignified pizza lovers who only want dressing or ranch on their veggies and those who love the taboo of putting ranch on their pizza. The container is iron and the board is mango wood.

So if you’re shopping for someone who has friends who fall into both categories—or if you’re shopping for someone who hosts a lot of pizza parties and needs this kind of thing to be ready for even the more incorrigible guests—this is the perfect gift to get them!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

I Love You 2 Pizzas Gift Basket

If you’re shopping for a special pizza gift for a special pizza lovers—especially if you’re in the dog house and have to grease some palms and bribe your way out—then this gift if perfect! Because pizza grease is, of course, the best option to grease said palms.

This great I love you 2 pizzas gift box is basically a pizza party in a box. It includes a $25 Papa John’s gift card, pizza shaped plates, a Ribbon Garland, a pizza banner, chef hats, a True Love notepad, pizza plushes, and a whole lot more!

This is truly one of the most unique pizza lovers gifts available. And, honestly, there’s no gift for pizza lovers that can truly compete with the gift of ‘za. So why try? This is truly one of the few fail-proof gifts you can get. And you can quote us on that.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via GoldIcingDesigns on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Steel Pizza Cutter

If you’re shopping for someone who has almost everything they need to be considered a true authority on pizza, this might be the perfect gift to complete their arsenal of pizza related accessories. The finishing touches are often the easiest to overlook.

This great steel pizza cutter is made in the vain of the Old World. It’s hand forged from steel and perfect for any pizza lover who also loves the spectacle of pizza making. No pizza making kit is complete without this kind of tool.

This is a great gift every pizza lover would cherish. It’ll also be a great way for them to feel transported to a simpler time—which is basically anytime before 2020, whether one year ago or a hundred years ago, when a simple slice of pizza was enough to offer solace.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

Best Gifts for Pizza LOverS OVER $100

So nothing has done it for you so far. And, if you’re willing to shell out this kind of cash, it’s probably safe to assume that your favorite food is something with a little more class. Like caviar or whatever folks with that kind of money indulge in.

But—still—we’re sure this special pizza lover in your life will be grateful for whatever pizza present you end up splurging on! If you’re still looking, it’s safe to assume you have pies to spare, so here are some more pizza gift ideas:


Reclaimed Wood Colored Cookbook Stands

If you’re shopping for a pizza lover who loves experimenting with new recipes, then you can’t go wrong with these! These are great for those folks who can’t work with anything but tangible, paper. Recipes sometimes require something more brick and mortar.

These great reclaimed wood colored cookbook stands are the perfect addition to any pizza making kit. They’re especially great because they’re easily forgotten. These stands are made out of 19th century reclaimed timber but have a modern design.

These are perfect gifts for any pizza lover who makes their own pizza. But, honestly, it could also be a great gift to encourage someone to try their hand at cooking. And if they’re any good, hopefully you’ll be rewarded with a lifetime supply of ‘za!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via UncommonGoods.com

A Wood Fired Pizza Oven

This is the kind of gift that every pizza lover probably dreams of getting. Because, honestly, there’s something incomparable about going into a pizza restaurant and seeing them pull the pies out of those vaunted contraptions.

These great wood fired pizza ovens are the perfect pizza related accessories. This is particularly good for someone with minimal DIY know-how. By mixing the 3 ingredients and following the simple instructions, they’ll have an oven they made themselves.

This is a great gift for any pizza lover. It’s perfect for pizza lovers who love showing off. Though if you’re shopping for someone who had a dream once upon a time of opening their own pizza shop, this might be the most touching gift you could get!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via BrickWoodOvens on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Set of Three Bread Boards

If you’re shopping for a pizza lover who already has everything—from the oven to the pizza cutter—maybe this is just what you need to get. Because you can never have too many of these kinds of tools at your disposal.

This great set of three bread boards comes with one small round board, one small rectangle board, and one medium rectangle board. It’s great for serving cheese and bread and transporting pizza. These are vintage pieces from the 1990s.

The nostalgia of this set might be what the recipient really appreciates. Or maybe they’ll just have a way of transporting their pizzas that makes them feel like they’re in an honest-to-goodness pizza shop. Whatever the reason—you can’t miss with this set!

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via ChaseVintage on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Pizza Neon Sign

Maybe you’re shopping for a pizza lover who’s a bit more new age. Maybe you’re shopping for a pizza lover who only loves eating pizza and doesn’t care about making. If that’s the case, this might be just what you need.

This pizza neon sign is the perfect pizza gift for pizza enthusiasts who are more enthusiastic about eating the pizza itself. These are handmade and they just ask that you contact them with color specifications and they’ll be more than accommodating.

So if you’re looking for that perfect pizza gift for the more unusual pizza lover, this might be it. Because, like with anything I suppose, even pizza has its own aesthetic. And I guess every aesthetic has its admirers.

Click here to check prices and reviews.

Photo via TheNaturalNeon on Etsy. Click here to browse their shop!

Finally: Some DIY Pizza Gifts

For an extra thoughtful touch, you might consider making your gift recipient a pizza themed gift from scratch. Here are some cute ideas:

  • These awesome DIY pizza pouch earrings as a gag gift
  • This cute DIY pizza box scrapbook
  • This adorable DIY pizza pop up card
Photo by Kristina Bratko on Unsplash

Hopefully our list helped you find the gift for pizza lovers you were looking for!

We’re confident we’ve given you a great, varied list of gifts any pizza lover would enjoy and appreciate. But, if you somehow didn’t find exactly what you were looking for, hopefully we were able to at least point you in the right direction!

It’s important to make this decision count—especially if you’re shopping for a pizza lover with connections­—and there’s plenty out there for you to choose from! Plus, and this might be wishful thinking, it might result in a few free pizza dinners if you nail it.

Leave a Comment