*FYI - this post may contain affiliate links, which means we earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you purchase from them. Also, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Check out our Privacy Policy and Disclosure. for more info.
Secret Santa is supposed to be cheap—part of what makes it so fun in the first place is the lack of pressure and expectation. So, if you’re currently shopping for your secret Santa gift exchange and looking for good secret Santa gifts under $5, we’ve got you covered!
If you’re participating in a secret Santa gift exchange this year, and there’s a hard cap that’s limited you to secret Santa gift ideas under $5, well, you should consider yourself lucky. After all, how often are you encouraged to spend less?
Whether you’re looking for cute secret Santa gifts under $5, good secret Santa gifts under $5, or simply great secret Santa gift ideas under $5, we’ve got you! We’ve scoured the Internet for the best secret Santa gifts under $5 so you don’t have to!
It doesn’t matter if you’re looking for multiple gifts to create secret Santa 10 dollar gift ideas or simply looking for $5 secret Santa gifts, we’re here to help. Here are the best secret Santa gifts under $5!
PS: Need more Secret Santa inspiration? Check out our other guides:
- 40+ Secret Santa Messages & Sayings to Steal This Christmas
- The Best Secret Santa Gifts for Him
- The Best Secret Santa Gifts for Her
- The Best Funny Secret Santa Gifts
- The Best Secret Santa Gifts for Your Boss
- Top Secret Santa Gifts Under $10
Pin these ideas for later:
Personalized Bath Bombs
If you’re looking for cute secret Santa gifts under $5, then look no further. These are particularly great for people who could use a little encouragement pampering themselves. After all, some people have a hard time doing that.
These awesome personalized bath bombs are some of the best secret Santa gifts under $5. You can even personalize the bath bomb label. They’re smaller than a tennis ball and come in sets of assorted scents.
So, if you’re participating in a secret Santa exchange—especially if you’re participating in a secret Santa with under $5 as the limit—you can’t go wrong with these. Self-care is underappreciated, and after 2020, we could all use a little bit more of it.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Starbucks Personalized Travel Mug Tumbler
This is perfect for that special someone who loves Starbucks. And, honestly, there aren’t many secret Santa presents under $5 that can even compete with this kind of thing. Because it’ll definitely come in handy for that special recipient.
This great personalized Starbucks travel mug tumbler is easily worth more than its diminutive price tag. You can personalize it with the name in various different places, and you can even select the primary color you want this mug to feature.
If you’re shopping for the kind of person who loves Starbucks, we understand your plight. It’s not exactly easy, especially since you can’t find Uggs for under $5 (unless you get them very, very used). This could be your saving grace!
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Frankenstein Light Switch
We all have friends who love Halloween. And I mean love—like, their Christmas is October 31st. Which I guess I understand. Regardless, this is sure to elicit at least a smile from the morbid recipient. Which is practically an admission of love for those types.
This great Frankenstein light switch is perfect for people who love all things horror—though if they love Frankenstein in particular (especially Gothic literature), this might hit a little closer to home. You can specify the primary color and wall plate style.
This is a great gift that’s sure to be fitting in that, um, eccentric recipient’s lair home. You can’t find many better spooky secret Santa gifts for such a low price, so if this is the vibe, I’d suggest you make the purchase already.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Christmas Toilet Paper
2020 has been a veritable nightmare. And, if you’re shopping for the kind of person who can still find the humor in such a disaster, then might be the perfect secret Santa gag gift under $5. Plus, this might be as good as money soon if things take another turn south.
This great Christmas toilet paper is the perfect symbol for the year we’ve all endured: it’s something we wish we could wipe off our, um, shoes. You can choose between four hilarious designs. Hopefully this toilet paper will at least lasts past New Years.
This is a great and hilarious gift that people with a particular sense of humor will definitely love. Or even if they don’t have that sense of humor—laughter’s sometimes the only antidote when times get tough. As they’ve gotten this year.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Reindeer Games Wax Melts
If you’re shopping for someone who loves the holiday aesthetic—like the reindeers and Santa and et cetera—and also someone who loves scented things (you’ll know if you’ve been to their home), this is probably the perfect gift!
These awesome reindeer games wax melts are handmade and cut in the shape of adorable reindeer heads (OK—that sounded cuter in my head). They’re redolent of plums, black cherry, amber, musk, and even a hint of citrus.
This is a great gift to get someone who would, you know, enjoy displaying this in their home, or even on their desk. But it’s also great for someone who could maybe stand to, well, experiment with some more congenial fragrances.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Peppermint Candies Christmas Candles
This is, again, a great gift for someone who loves both the holiday aesthetic and someone who loves scented things. And, honestly, is there any home better than a home that feels like the harbinger of the holiday spirit?
These great peppermint candies Christmas candles are perfect for that kind of person. You can select between a variety of sizes, and whether the candles will have a label or not. They’re handmade and smell like a blend of peppermint and vanilla.
This might be perfect for someone who’s always baking cookies—because, at least for me, these kinds of things always get me in the mood to eat. But they’re also great for anyone who loves holiday scents in general.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
2020 Wine Label
If you’re shopping for someone who’s had a really rough go of it (as we all have) this year—especially someone who spent quarantine overindulging in their favorite vino—this might be the perfect gift to get them.
This great 2020 wine label (paired with a bottle of wine if your budget allows) is the perfectly relatable gift we all need for Secret Santa this year, offering an apt one-star review of this foxhole of a year we’re leaving.
So if you’re shopping for someone who has turned to wine as one of their few reliable companions during this trying time—then this might be the perfect gift! Plus, maybe they’ll invite you over for a glass or two. We could all use commiseration at this point.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Grinch Poop
If you’re shopping for someone who likes the Grinch—or maybe someone you don’t know well enough to find a sentimental gift for—this could be perfect. It could also, admittedly, be a great way to telegraph how you feel about some. But that’s on you.
This Grinch poop gag gift is sure to get at least a chuckle (but that’s the bare minimum here). It’s important to make the recipient aware that, while there might be some, er, food-chunks in these bags, they shouldn’t eat them.
So if you’re shopping for someone who’s been really naughty and coal doesn’t feel like a harsh enough gift, this could be just what you’re looking for. Because, well, real poop isn’t as inconspicuous. And you’d have to deal with the smell of that too.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Santa Cam
This is a great gift to give someone who either a) is a tad more voyeuristic than most or b) is a bit of a fake cop around the office or home. Or maybe this would just be perfect for someone who’s a little paranoid.
Regardless of whom you’re shopping for, this Santa cam could be a great and hilarious gift. You can select between either a pin back or magnet (we prefer the magnet).
This is a great gift people with a bit more self-awareness would appreciate—though it’s also a great gift to suggest to someone that, well, you’re onto them. And while they think they’re keeping an eye on you, you’re actually keeping an eye on them.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Funny Magnet
If you work with someone who isn’t afraid to let profanities fly—or maybe you’re shopping for a friend who you know lets profanities fly when they’re on the clock—this could be a hilarious gift to get them!
This great and hilarious work gift comes with a, um, relatable quote. Especially if anyone’s ever worked in the service industry. Especially if anyone’s worked at a Subway. (There’s a chance I’m projecting here…)
These gifts would be perfect to display on a refrigerator or a desk. And, for the right kind of person, this gift might as well be a badge of honor. And they’ll probably display it like a wartime decoration, too. Because, in some ways, that’s just what it is.
Click here to check prices and reviews.
Hopefully our list helped you find the perfect secret Santa gift for under $5 you were looking for!
We’re confident we’ve provided you with a great and varied list of the best $5 secret Santa gifts available. And, if we didn’t, hopefully we were able to at least point you in the direction of the perfect secret Santa Gifts under 5 dollars you’re looking for.
This isn’t a gift purchase you want to take lightly—who knows when the tables will be turned and you’ll be banking on their magnanimity. Then you’ll be wishing you would’ve put more thought into this gift exchange.